Establishing psychological safety in a team
A common area that leaders and coaches use Ask David to explore is establishing psychological safety in a team.
By David Clutterbuck · 3 min read
A common area that leaders and coaches use Ask David to explore further is around establishing psychological safety in a team. Ask David is proving to be a rich source of insight into issues, where leaders and coaches value a thinking partner to explore challenging topics like this one.
Frequent concerns raised relate to:
- How to raise the topic, when executive teams don’t want to admit it’s a problem
- What kinds of exercise help, and how?
- How to establish psychological safety within a hierarchy, where junior people feel vulnerable.
No relationship is 100% psychologically safe
A fundamental point here is that no relationship, even with close family members, is 100% psychologically safe. Even in a loving husband and wife relationship, there are thoughts we keep to ourselves, if only to protect our partner. What matters in a team is firstly, the general level of psychological safety and secondly, the degree, to which high or low levels of psychological safety affect individual and collective performance.
The four stages of psychological safety
Timothy R Clarke in his book “The Four Stages Of Psychological Safety” describes a conceptual model of four “stages” of psychological safety that teams can move through, progressing from stage 1 to stage 4.
These four stages are:
- Inclusion Safety – members feel safe to belong to the team. They are comfortable being present, do not feel excluded, and feel like they are wanted and appreciated.
- Learner Safety – members are able to learn through asking questions. Team members here may be able to experiment, make (and admit) small mistakes, and ask for help.
- Contributor Safety – members feel safe to contribute their own ideas, without fear of embarrassment or ridicule. This is a more challenging state, because volunteering your own ideas can increase the psychosocial vulnerability of team members.
- Challenger Safety – members can question others’ (including those in authority) ideas or suggest significant changes to ideas, plans, or ways of working.
A practical starting point
There is little evidence that teams go through these stages sequentially but the categories provide a useful framework for exploring concepts with a team.
A practical starting point with a team is to share that psychological safety is never absolute. How much psychological safety does this team need to function at its best? That provides an opening to administer a psychological safety questionnaire (such as CCMI’s, available here) that provides a benchmark to compare the current reality with the desired state.
A frequent enquiry of Ask David is for practical exercises to use. Here are two powerful ones:
Tell us a story
Everyone is invited to tell a personal story of a time of great joy, sadness or both. When one or two people choose to be vulnerable, others feel better able to follow suit.
Best team in the world
Ask everyone to imagine a team, in which everyone felt empowered and supported to perform at their best. What kind of conversations would happen? How could we make such conversations the norm for this team?
If you are looking for a trusted AI thinking partner, please do try my AI clone - Ask David. You can engage in a short demonstration or sign up for a 7 day free trial.
Questions
Can a team be 100% psychologically safe?
No. No relationship, even with close family members, is 100% psychologically safe. What matters in a team is the general level of psychological safety and the degree to which high or low levels of it affect individual and collective performance.
What are the four stages of psychological safety?
Inclusion safety, where members feel safe to belong; learner safety, where they can ask questions, experiment and admit small mistakes; contributor safety, where they can offer their own ideas without fear of ridicule; and challenger safety, where they can question others’ ideas, including those in authority.
Do teams move through the four stages in order?
There is little evidence that teams go through these stages sequentially, but the categories provide a useful framework for exploring concepts with a team.
Where should a coach start with psychological safety in a team?
Share that psychological safety is never absolute and ask how much this team needs to function at its best. That opens the way to a psychological safety questionnaire, which gives a benchmark to compare the current reality with the desired state.